A general picture of Huntington's argument:
- Great division among humankind will be cultural instead of ideological and primarily economic.
- Non-Western civilizations no longer remain the objects of history as targets of Western colonialism but join the West as movers and shapers of history.
- Civilization: Highest cultural grouping people, broadest level of cultural identity people that distinguishes humans from other species.
- Two major variants: European-North American
- Islam has its three subdivisions: Arab, Turkic and Malay.
- Civilizations differ from each other by history, language, culture, tradition and religion.
- Cultural identity turns into civilization consciousness.
- Why civilizations will crash?
o
Differences among civilizations have generated
the most prolonged and the most violent conflicts.
o
Increasing interactions intensify civilization
consciousness and awareness of differences between civilizations and
commonalities within civilizations.
o
Economic modernization and social change weaken
the national state as a source of identity and this provides a basis for
broader ‘civilization’ identity.
o
Westernization provides a return to roots of the
civilization. It makes people also desire to identify themselves different.
o
Cultural characteristics cannot be converted to
another identity and this strengthens the devotion to the belonging
civilization. The question was ‘which side are you on?’ but now ‘What are you?’
No half/half persons.
o
Successful economic regionalism will reinforce
civilization-consciousness.
- People define themselves ‘us’ in religious and ethnic terms while define others as ‘them’
- The efforts of the West to promote its values of democracy and liberalism as universal values, to maintain military predominance and to advance its economic interests.
- The clash occurs in two levels: micro-level, macro-level.
- Fault line between civilizations.
- In the Arab world, Western democracy strengthens anti-Western political forces.
- Differences in power and struggles for military, economic and institutional power are one source of conflict between the West and other civilizations.
- Differences in culture (basic values and beliefs) are second source of conflict.
- The West induces other peoples to adopt Western ideas concerning democracy and human rights.
- They have to either isolate themselves from the World or join the West and accept its values or balance it by modernize but no westernize.
- Torn country: they want to join but they can’t because of historical, cultural and traditional aspects. (Turkey, Mexico, Russia)
- To redefine their civilization identity torn countries must meet three requirements:
o
The support and enthusiasm of economic and
political elite.
o
The public has to accept even if they don’t
want.
o
The dominant groups have to be willing to
convert
- Western civilization is both Western and modern. Non-western civilizations have attempted to become modern without becoming Western. (p.49)
- There will be no universal civilization, but instead a world of different civilizations.